Australia's unseen sovereign capability gaps
I've recently been up in Canberra for work, I first attended the Southern Space conference, then was involved in policy discussions of the SOCI act and various topics that involve Australia's sovereign capabilities. I then went from Canberra directly to Sydney to continue my work on finding a local manufacturing supply chain for a space related project I'm working on. It turns out building something in Australia can be both easier than expected for some things but also harder than expected for other things.
The accuracy of what people assess as being easy to do on shore and not is the topic that keeps coming up and frankly it bothers me greatly what I'm finding. The issue is that Australia has a bunch of enormous gaps in local capabilities that people are unaware of while simultaneously having a variety of industries that think there's no local supply chain when really there is. This is a metacognitive gap crisis. The last couple of months have let me understand a critical part of why sovereign capabilities is such an issue in Australia, people don't know what we can make here and they don't know what Australia's society and government relies on here that we don't make locally.
On the way from Canberra to Sydney I noticed that there was a phone on the train:

This phone didn't work and said it was out of radio contact, but I think in this case the radio system it was built upon just doesn't exist anymore. The radio phone just sits here as a weirdly placed artefact of an era where locals made telecommunications equipment for other locals in local factories. Now everyone on the train is just using their mobile phones to make a call, but not all of the journey is within mobile phone cellular reception areas. This means if the mobile network goes down the trains go down because the drivers are using this too. And this is no hypothetical, this has already happened due to a PNT outage this year.
The radio phone is almost a museum piece to a local capability that has died, but yet this is not a museum, it's just near the buffet car on the train where you can get some food and a tea/coffee while travelling to Sydney. While in line I noticed that the buffet car has some point of sale system that's hooked up to some old version of Microsoft Windows. While this works, Microsoft's products are yet another foreign product from a foreign supply chain that Australian society has an almost complete dependence on. We could set up things with Linux that the local supply chain could both own and maintain, but yet many such systems exist that are both not locally owned and not even supported by the original overseas manufacturers. While waiting for some food I spent a considerable amount of time thinking about this. Given it's a long trip you have time to think. It was nice to be able to take a train from Canberra to Sydney, even though it took a bit longer it was nice to have some legroom and also just to take a moment to process all the things that had come up in the previous week.
People don't really get enough downtime anymore to really think through things and I think this is a far more significant part of the sovereign supply chain crisis than it might appear. This is to say that a large part of why we have a sovereign supply chain crisis in Australia is because we simply don't think about it enough.
I had a meeting at Macquarie University in Sydney on the Friday and I had to make it back to the airport to get to Melbourne. It was great to be able to get on the newly built metro as this cut down the travel time enormously. One thing you'll notice about the Sydney metro is that there's no human driver in the train. Which means that the metro train network is directly dependent on advanced electronics, signalling and also PNT capabilities.
Australia has a strong dependency on foreign suppliers for these capabilities, the PNT system in particular is now a critical make-or-break dependency for the trains since there is no human driver. In other words the electronics is now doing positioning, navigation and timing instead of a human. This is a strong dependency on a variety of systems that Australia may not operate or create the parts for in the local supply chain but yet the entire society is now getting very much dependent on.
With a human driver you have a fallback if things go wrong, it's not great but things are recoverable. In the Sydney metro there's no signalling lights at all. A human driver cannot be easily inserted into this system if there's a problem with the electronics or cyber systems that runs this network. This means that in a very serious cyber outage incident a large part of the transportation network is now at risk of not running at all, which is considerably worse than the degraded-but-still-operational system that would be possible to operate if there was human intervention available.
As I was on the tarmac there was a refuelling truck putting fuel into the aeroplane. Most people on the plane were doom scrolling on their phones or otherwise engaging in mindless entertainment but I was thinking about the fuel supply.

The Sydney to Melbourne flight corridor is one of the most busy in the world. Where do we get the fuel for those planes? Turns out we import a LOT of this fuel.
On the way back from Melbourne airport I had the moment that caused me to write this blog post. Because there's no airport rail in Melbourne, which I think is an unacceptable sovereign capability gap honestly, I ended up getting an Uber. Uber of course is a foreign owned app, and most people are using that app to the point where there are whole areas in the airport just dedicated to rideshare pickups. When you book a ride it pops up a map that shows where the car is at that point in time, this is a dependency on GPS and GNSS systems and also on the phone app store ecosystem. Australia runs neither the GPS or phone app stores, but yet has a society absolutely and completely dependent on those systems.
On the drive out of the airport there's a place called Direct Factory Outlets.
This was the point of the journey where I felt I couldn't help but write this blog post. A factory outlet implies a factory. A direct outlet implies that the factory is nearby or at the very least in the same country. The language here is manipulative because the implication is that buying directly from the factory will save you money, but of course this is a retail shopping center not an industrial location. So how far away are the factories that are supplying the "direct" outlets? Who owns those supply chains?
Almost nobody asks these questions, so I figure I will.
DFO an example of the sovereign supply chain questions that we don't ask
A quick analysis of a purpose built "factory outlets venue" tells a story about Australian local capabilities.
Firstly it's worth mentioning that this place was purpose built as retail, the factories were never there. It's a simulacrum situation. This might seem like a nitpick but it's really not, much of Australia's manufacturing marketing is like this in some way or another.
At this location there are 118 retail and 13 food shops.
Curiously some companies have more than one shop there, so much for "direct" from the factory being a way to cut costs or retailers. People see "direct from factory" and think disintermediation is occurring, but in this case there's companies having more than one store in a venue that advertises itself as "direct". Adairs has three, Palermo two.
Sovereign ownership
Roughly 77 are Australian-founded and still Australian-headquartered, or about 59%.
Local supply chain
Direct from a factory doesn't necessarily answer who owns the factory but it sets the mental framing that if you are getting something direct from a factory that the factory is nearby.
The food shops are for the most part going to have to source local ingredients just as a part of their operations. So let's do a quick analysis of the other stores that are non-food.
Here's the bit that really isn't so pleasant.
Nearly every "Australian" fashion label at the centre manufactures nothing in Australia. In this case "direct" from the factory includes a very long supply chain where goods literally move from thousands of kilometers and continents away via very large container ships that also are not flagged in Australia. But how direct is this?
Only 25-35 of the stores carry anything at all that was made in Australia.
The meta problem that matters for Australia
For the most part people have no idea how indirect and convoluted the supply chains are that Australian society is now entirely dependent on. We own less of our supply chain than people assume and we operate less of our supply chain locally than people assume.
There's a very significant metacognitive gap here, people think Australia operates more than it does and therefore are robbed of the opportunity to identify the depth of the problem facing the country.
The "meta problem" is that society here is structured in such a way that people aren't going to discover just how bad this problem really is until crises occur in the supply chain which is likely going to be too late for interventions to easily come in.
Imagine someone has a very complex legal issue to deal with, if they outsourced this work to a specialist like a lawyer nobody would think twice. And before AI emerged nobody really did think twice, they'd just outsource this to a lawyer.
There's many other situations where it entirely makes sense to get professional advice.
Then there's other situations where people could do something themselves but maybe they do or don't. For example there's people who hire cleaners or people to work in the yard. This may or may not be a great decision but it's hard to know without knowing more about the circumstances.
But if someone didn't know how to use cutlery or chopsticks and hired someone to do this to enable them to eat their own food we wouldn't think this was a good thing. Sure there may be an economic arrangement that could be made here, and indeed this is what is made when there's profound disability involved, but we see this lack of ability as a disability. In the word disability it is hinted at that there is a lack of ability.
We assume that for the basic maintenance of someone's life they should be able to do basic tasks, like feed themselves, and if they can't do this it's not a good thing. Sure they may be able to get someone else to do it, but this doesn't make their lack of ability to look after themselves now magically a good thing, this is because without that help they still can't do crucial activities. If the help does not arrive on time the person would eventually starve.
The sovereign capabilities issue that Australia is facing is much like this, as a nation Australia is starting to lose the capacity to do some very basic things like clothe its population or secure fuel. Sure we can buy clothes in from somewhere else, but the fact we are slowly losing that local supply chain as an option is not a positive at all.
Australia has many sheep and exports wool but yet we do not spin wool here. We export these things and then re-import the products. The fact we can import these products does not mean our inability to do it ourselves is a good thing.
Having money to fix a problem doesn't make the problem being fixed with money not a problem.